Xbox 360 2010 Game of the Year

Halo Reach for me because of all the replay value and because it's so much fucking fun.

Note: This is just about Xbox 360 exclusives and Xbox 360/PC games.

Do you mean just Xbox 360 exclusives? Cause otherwise ME2 needs to be on that list.

Halo Reach FTW!Awesome multiplayer.

Mass effect probably deserves it most, followed up by halo.
But I think reachs campaign is dull and so I decided to give this one to alan wake.

TheJubJub5721 wrote:

Do you mean just Xbox 360 exclusives? Cause otherwise ME2 needs to be on that list.

Shouldn't really include that as it will be available for PS3 in January (Using the Mass Effect 3 engine, and all the DLC for free)

EPICAlan wrote:

Halo Reach for me because of all the replay value and because it's so much fucking fun.

Note: This is just about Xbox 360 exclusives and Xbox 360/PC games.

That's not exclusive, it's coming to the PS3 in a matter of weeks and the demo for it is already out.

D_Homes wrote:

TheJubJub5721 wrote:

Do you mean just Xbox 360 exclusives? Cause otherwise ME2 needs to be on that list.

Shouldn't really include that as it will be available for PS3 in January (Using the Mass Effect 3 engine, and all the DLC for free)

It's not out yet this year, so it can count in this years GOTY

TheJubJub5721 wrote:

D_Homes wrote:

TheJubJub5721 wrote:

Do you mean just Xbox 360 exclusives? Cause otherwise ME2 needs to be on that list.

Shouldn't really include that as it will be available for PS3 in January (Using the Mass Effect 3 engine, and all the DLC for free)

It's not out yet this year, so it can count in this years GOTY

That's a bit of a stretch though. The whole idea about 360 exclusives and 360/PC games is about iconic 360 games. Mass Effect 2 really isn't iconic anymore now that Bioware has been advertising the PS3 version like crazy. Although I still think Mass Effect series is better played on the 360.

Mass Effect 2 should be on the list since it's not on the PS3 yet. Once it hits PS3, then you should include that in 2011's Best PS3 Game list.

TRF wrote:

Mass Effect 2 should be on the list since it's not on the PS3 yet. Once it hits PS3, then you should include that in 2011's Best PS3 Game list.

just kidding
Good solution.

TRF wrote:

Mass Effect 2 should be on the list since it's not on the PS3 yet. Once it hits PS3, then you should include that in 2011's Best PS3 Game list.

That's kind of dumb. The second part of your proposal is even dumber. I mean people are only counting it NOW because it's not on the PS3. How would it be a "2011 exclusive" if it has already been released on the 360/PC. I mean it's not even a slightly modified version like Ninja Gaiden Sigma or something, it's a port of the original.

EPICAlan wrote:

TRF wrote:

Mass Effect 2 should be on the list since it's not on the PS3 yet. Once it hits PS3, then you should include that in 2011's Best PS3 Game list.

That's kind of dumb. The second part of your proposal is even dumber. I mean people are only counting it NOW because it's not on the PS3. How would it be a "2011 exclusive" if it has already been released on the 360/PC. I mean it's not even a slightly modified version like Ninja Gaiden Sigma or something, it's a port of the original.

Because it's one of the best games the 360 and PC has to offer. Next year, it will be one of the best PS3 has to offer.

TRF wrote:

EPICAlan wrote:

TRF wrote:

Mass Effect 2 should be on the list since it's not on the PS3 yet. Once it hits PS3, then you should include that in 2011's Best PS3 Game list.

That's kind of dumb. The second part of your proposal is even dumber. I mean people are only counting it NOW because it's not on the PS3. How would it be a "2011 exclusive" if it has already been released on the 360/PC. I mean it's not even a slightly modified version like Ninja Gaiden Sigma or something, it's a port of the original.

Because it's one of the best games the 360 and PC has to offer. Next year, it will be one of the best PS3 has to offer.

That's what the multiplatform GOTY is for isn't it?

EPICAlan wrote:

TRF wrote:

EPICAlan wrote:

TRF wrote:

Mass Effect 2 should be on the list since it's not on the PS3 yet. Once it hits PS3, then you should include that in 2011's Best PS3 Game list.

That's kind of dumb. The second part of your proposal is even dumber. I mean people are only counting it NOW because it's not on the PS3. How would it be a "2011 exclusive" if it has already been released on the 360/PC. I mean it's not even a slightly modified version like Ninja Gaiden Sigma or something, it's a port of the original.

Because it's one of the best games the 360 and PC has to offer. Next year, it will be one of the best PS3 has to offer.

That's what the multiplatform GOTY is for isn't it?

But it's not on PS3 yet, this year. So it should still be up for Xbox 360 GOTY

TheJubJub5721 wrote:

EPICAlan wrote:

TRF wrote:

EPICAlan wrote:

TRF wrote:

Mass Effect 2 should be on the list since it's not on the PS3 yet. Once it hits PS3, then you should include that in 2011's Best PS3 Game list.

That's kind of dumb. The second part of your proposal is even dumber. I mean people are only counting it NOW because it's not on the PS3. How would it be a "2011 exclusive" if it has already been released on the 360/PC. I mean it's not even a slightly modified version like Ninja Gaiden Sigma or something, it's a port of the original.

Because it's one of the best games the 360 and PC has to offer. Next year, it will be one of the best PS3 has to offer.

That's what the multiplatform GOTY is for isn't it?

But it's not on PS3 yet, this year. So it should still be up for Xbox 360 GOTY

I disagree but I understand why you think that. In my mindset it's not really an iconic 360 game anymore. Isn't GOTY awards for specific platform games supose to be about iconic games for that platform?

EPICAlan wrote:

I disagree but I understand why you think that. In my mindset it's not really an iconic 360 game anymore. Isn't GOTY awards for specific platform games supose to be about iconic games for that platform?

That makes sense, but I still think since it's not out on PS3 you should be able to vote for it.

As much as I loved Alan Wake, there was really no reason to go back and play it again. I picked Halo Reach because of the replay value and it's fun.

I have to say Fable 3, due to the fact that i like it more then Reach.

Fable III ;

I fucking love that game. I really hope whatever Lionhead do next they keep it similar to the Fable series. There's nothing like it on the market.

Sovereign Alan wrote:

EPICAlan wrote:

Halo Reach for me because of all the replay value and because it's so much fucking fun.

Note: This is just about Xbox 360 exclusives and Xbox 360/PC games.

That's not exclusive, it's coming to the PS3 in a matter of weeks and the demo for it is already out.

I highly doubt that, Alan.

TheJubJub5721 wrote:

EPICAlan wrote:

I disagree but I understand why you think that. In my mindset it's not really an iconic 360 game anymore. Isn't GOTY awards for specific platform games supose to be about iconic games for that platform?

That makes sense, but I still think since it's not out on PS3 you should be able to vote for it.

I totally agree. It came out on pc and 360, the systems which got the first game. That alone is enough reason to give priority to pc/360 gamers and let them vote for it otherwise it's silly, because ps3 players can't vote for it when they've not played it, so effectively, it's a 360 title this year. Plus, it's been out practically a whole year on just 360 and pc, it's a timed exclusive, the ps3 version is as good as non-existent for now.

@Alan
Dude, as of right now you can ONLY get 360 and PC version of Mass Effect.So it does count until it comes out on PS3(which has not happened yet)

I don't see it as exclusive. Hell I don't even see it as an iconic 360 game. But if it REALLY bothers you guys that much, I'll add it okay?

EDIT:

Errr.. Sorry to those that originally meant to vote for ME2 but had voted for something else because the option was not there before.

Sovereign Alan wrote:

I don't see it as exclusive. Hell I don't even see it as an iconic 360 game. But if it REALLY bothers you guys that much, I'll add it okay?

EDIT:

Errr.. Sorry to those that originally meant to vote for ME2 but had voted for something else because the option was not there before.

Allow vote cancelling.