Halo 5: Guardians vs. Uncharted 4: A Thief's End

Whichever one is more original.

So either of them?

Neither

They're both quite meh, at the moment.

Honestly? Neither really...
Uncharted more than Halo though. I really don't give a shit about Halo, just the multiplayer interests me. I don't think Uncharted is all that great either but at least it's cinematic and engaging.

The flaws are that Halo has boring story and repetitive gameplay, Uncharted is horribly linear and scripted

That being said, content-wise and replayability-wise it's guaranteed that Halo will actually have the edge. Especially if it has co-op like previous games. But I still am more interested in Uncharted 4.

BUT a more apt comparison would be Gears of War 4 vs Uncharted 4. Except Gears ain't coming till later and we don't know anything about it yet.

There's nothing to do in Halo. All installments after 3 have been a waste of time, and this'll be no different.

Uncharted always has more re-playability. Replaying a Halo campaign is just tedium.

Reviews are in...

http://www.metacritic.com/game/xbox-one/halo-5-guardians

Mecha wrote:

Reviews are in...

http://www.metacritic.com/game/xbox-one/halo-5-guardians

I feel like because the FPS genre is so saturated and that there is so much overlap when it comes to game mechanics that pretty much every big-name FPS is destined to get a metacritic score in the 70-85 range.

Uncharted. Halo can go do one.